Chapter 3: Keep the Flame Burning…

ON A JANUARY DAY in 1844, the nation’s secretary of state described the condition of colored America. The 1840 Census showed that free Negroes in the North were dissolute and degraded, and prone to illness, lunacy, and suicide. The cause was clear, John C. Calhoun, who hailed from Charleston, said. Freedom made Negroes crazy.

Calhoun, the young nation’s emissary to an increasingly antislavery world, said the South’s 2.7 million slaves lived better than their 171,000 free Northern counterparts: Slaveholders provided shelter, a meal on the table, and a moral life. Statisticians doubted his claim. A black physician, James McCune Smith, said the census showed free Negroes outliving slaves by an average of seven years. Calhoun brushed these critics aside, insisting that Northern Negroes led lives of “vice and pauperism.”

More Excerpts



View all Excerpts »


Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Connect with Catto's History

Meet the Authors

When they are not writing, Dan Biddle and Murray Dubin love to talk -- especially about the book. Invite them to speak to your book club, church, college class, civil war commemoration, fraternal group, library event, historical association meeting and more.
Find out More >

Become our Fan

Follow Tasting Freedom on Facebook for announcements.

Video Introduction



We like to talk. Our publicist put us in front of a video camera, asked three questions and then crossed his fingers. We're probably a little too serious at the beginning, but we loosen up as the video goes on.
Take a look >

A Call to Arms

Click to get a closer look, you can see the name of Octavius Catto at the bottom, as well as his father's.

This broadside is eight feet high and was seen on windows in downtown Philadelphia in June, 1863, as black leaders called a meeting to convince black men to join the Union Army prior to Gettysburg.